This article includes references to mental health and suicide.
Improving mental health in the creative industries requires more than supporting individuals, as important as this is. Following our release last week of the Job Quality in the Creative Industries report, Creative PEC Research Fellow George Musgrave argues that changing the conditions of creative work is essential to delivering the Good Work agenda, and introduces a new framework designed to help organisations do just that.
The creative industries have become increasingly concerned with the mental health and wellbeing of workers. This has emerged in response to research over the past decade showing high levels of anxiety, depression, burnout and – in UK and US data – even elevated rates of suicide in the sector. Much of this work has been excellently brought together in a recent book by Mark Deuze entitled What Makes You Happy Can Also Make You Sick, unpacking the specific combination of challenges facing workers in the creative industries, including: high levels of self-employment and thus weaker labour market protections, precarious funding streams engendering intense pressure, as well as a reliance on informal social networks in a sector perceived as prestigious meaning abuses of power often go unchallenged.
Against this backdrop, from music, film and television, to video games and the performing arts, we have seen the development of a range of vital mental health interventions: counselling services, in-house therapy, telephone helplines, peer-support networks and forms of health-focused training. These initiatives are crucial, providing much-needed support to people experiencing considerable difficulties.
However, we cannot expect to make creative work healthier by only helping creative workers become better at coping with unhealthy conditions. We need to go further, and more fundamentally address the organisation of creative work.
From Good Work principles, to better workplaces
In 2023, Creative PEC’s Good Work Review challenged policymakers to look beyond the growth of the creative economy and consider the quality of the jobs it creates. The Review identified six dimensions of Good Work: fair reward, security and flexibility, autonomy, healthy and inclusive environments, worker voice, and opportunities for development and progression.
Its second strategic priority called for improvements in management and workplace practices. Recommendations included sector-specific Good Work standards, accreditation, stronger links between public funding and employment practices, and better resources to support organisational improvement. Last week, the Creative PEC report ‘Job quality in the creative industries’ revealed an empirically mixed picture; workers experiencing high levels of autonomy on the one hand, alongside high levels of job insecurity and high levels of work-related illness caused by stress, anxiety or depression on the other. In response the report called for “a need to drive adoption of Good or Fair Work standards across the creative industries.” This call was amplified in a joint statement by Arts Council England, ALBA Chruthachail, Arts Council of Wales, Youth Music, Creative Wales, BFI and DCMS, articulating a public commitment to “tackle workforce challenges to build a resilient, fit-for-the-future workforce including by improving job quality, retention and progression.”
These are important aims. But how should these ambitions be realised practically?
As the Good Work Review’s recommendations acknowledge, improving working conditions requires interventions at multiple levels.
We can think of this at three levels. At the individual (micro) level, creative workers need access to mental health services and support to navigate demanding careers. At the structural (macro) level, government and industry bodies together can strengthen employment protections and seek to address inequalities of various kinds, from discriminatory practices to unfairness in the tax system. But between these sits the organisational (meso) level: the everyday decisions about the nuts and bolts of creative work: workloads, deadlines, commissioning, management, accountability and worker participation, all of which shape how creative work is experienced.
Each layer is complementary. For example, counselling may help someone experiencing burnout and help reduce symptoms of anxiety, while stronger employment protections can address wider insecurity. However, neither of these necessarily change wider organisational cultures which might, at least in part (as research from organisational psychology has shown), contribute to a person’s psychosocial strain at work.
Translating good intentions into organisational practice
This is the challenge that the Creative Labour Sustainability Framework (CLSF) has been developed to address.
Drawing on research into creative labour, occupational health and organisational practice – and my 15 years experience in researching mental health in the music industry around the world – the CLSF was published earlier this year in the Creative Industries Journal. It provides a structured approach for creative organisations to examine how their working arrangements may expose people to psychosocial risks, and where improvements might be made.
It considers five interconnected domains:
- Structural exposure: How organisations identify and manage workload intensity.
- Power, voice and redress: Whether workers can raise concerns and access meaningful mechanisms for resolving problems.
- Duty of care infrastructure: How responsibility for worker wellbeing is established
- Risk anticipation and learning: Whether organisations identify emerging problems, learn from previous experiences and improve their practices.
- Transitions and longevity: How working arrangements support sustainable careers, including through periods of change or interruption.
Let’s take an example. Consider a music venue preparing for a particularly intensive period of programming. Staff and freelancers alike may face long hours, compressed turnaround times and various competing demands which may make their jobs increasingly stressful. The organisation might offer wellbeing resources, but does it systematically examine cumulative workloads? Are concerns raised by workers recorded and acted upon? Are lessons from previous periods of excessive demand incorporated into future planning? Does it have formal policies in place?
These questions illustrate an important distinction i.e. between expressing a commitment to wellbeing and demonstrating how that commitment shapes organisational decisions to improve outcomes for workers.
How will the CLSF work? Organisations will be able to download the tool, and then convene their top team (precise members will vary depending on the size and structure of the company) to spend a few hours working through each of the 5 domains. In each area, those undertaking the assessment will be asked to reflect on how well they can produce evidence that they meet a series of statements concerning the policies and processes they have in place to pre-empt, respond to, and learn from sources of psychosocial stress in their organisation. Each domain will generate a private banding score (Emerging, Established, or Robust), and the CLSF will suggest how to strengthen the score over the next 12 months. Organisations will get a kitemark for their website to publicly show their commitment to strengthening mental health in their workplace, without revealing their score.
The CLSF encourages organisations to examine evidence of their practices, identify gaps and consider improvements. It is, of course, not a replacement for employment law or collective bargaining. Its contribution is more specific than this: to provide a practical approach to help organisations translate their good intentions into organisational practice.
Good Work beyond employment contracts
It is important to acknowledge that much creative work is undertaken by people who are not permanent employees.
For example, a festival may employ a relatively small permanent team but depends on hundreds of freelance performers, technicians and production workers – from bar staff to security teams. Its internal employment practices might be exemplary, while freelancers experience unpredictable schedules, challenging turnaround times, difficulties raising concerns, or other stressors connected their precarious working arrangements.
Can an organisation reasonably claim to provide ‘Good Work’ if its own employees are well supported but the freelancers on whom it depends are less well supported?
Organisations may not directly employ freelance workers, but they can nevertheless shape the conditions under which they work. Thus, the CLSF Assessment will ask organisations to consider the wider reach of their decisions, including their impact on freelancers and contractors, by considering not only their employees, but their wider ‘creative labour reach’.
A single organisation cannot resolve every problem facing creative workers, of course. Many risks arise from wider market conditions, funding arrangements, fragmented employment relationships, or working cultures which are not specific to any one company and are outside of their personal control. But we know from occupational health research that organisations do exercise influence on the wellbeing of their workforce, and by taking responsibility for the working conditions they can reasonably change have the potential to positively impact the wellbeing of their workforce.
Making Good Work happen
Creative PEC’s Good Work Review established an important agenda for improving job quality. The challenge now is translating its principles into everyday organisational practice.
The CLSF offers just one contribution to that process. Its application across different creative settings will need continued testing and evaluation – and it is currently in a pilot phase across the UK music industry in partnership with the charity Music Minds Matter. However, its underlying proposition is, in fact, straightforward: that organisations need ways to understand the risks associated with how work is structured, to assess their own practices, and to learn how to improve them too. The aim of the tool is simpler still, captured in its strapline: building healthier creative workplaces.
There remains an open question as to whether voluntary interventions in the absence of legislative muscle can produce significant, sector-wide change. Furthermore, there is no single intervention that will make creative work healthier. Progress requires action from individuals, organisations, industry bodies and government, working at different levels and addressing different dimensions of the problem. But if we are serious about ‘Good Work’, we must pay attention not only to how we support creative workers, but to the conditions under which they are expected to create.
Good Work cannot simply be something the creative industries promise. It must become something they build, together.
If you or someone you know is struggling, free 24/7 support is available in the UK. Call Samaritans on 116 123 or text SHOUT to 85258 to reach Shout. For urgent NHS mental health help, call 111.
References:
Carey, H., Giles, L., & O’Brien, D. (2023) Job quality in the Creative Industries The final report from the Creative PEC’s Good Work Review, Creative PEC
Carey, H., Wang, R., & O’Brien, D. (2026) Job quality in the creative industries, 2026. Creative PEC State of the Nations research series.
DCMS (2026) Statement on principles of Good and Fair Work in the creative industries and culture sector: https://www.gov.uk/guidance/statement-on-principles-of-good-and-fair-work-in-the-creative-industries-and-culture-sector
Deuze, M. (2025) Wellbeing and Creative Careers: What Makes You Happy Can Also Make You Sick, Intellect Books
Musgrave, G. (2026) The ‘Creative Labour Sustainability Framework’: Developing a Governance-Oriented Risk Assessment for Harm Prevention in the Creative Industries, Creative Industries Journal
Musgrave, G. & Lamis, D. (2025) Musicians, the music industry, and suicide: Epidemiology, risk factors, and suggested prevention approaches, Frontiers in Public Health, 13:1507772
van der Molen, H. F., K. Nieuwenhuijsen, M. H. W. Frings-Dresen, and G. de Groene. (2020). Work-Related Psychosocial Risk Factors for Stress-Related Mental Disorders: An Updated Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. BMJ Open 10 (7): e034849.
